Pilates? Yoga? What's The Difference?

female yoga teacher assisting a student in extended warrior post and a female pilates teacher demonstrating mermaid on the reformer and double straight leg stretch on the mat

Over the years, both Pilates and yoga have been a big part of my life. Through these practices, I’ve:

  • Managed and resolved chronic stiffness, pain and joint instability in my neck and low back

  • Learned to breathe (this may not sound like much but learning to breathe in a way that eases - rather than creates - tension, soothes an over-stressed mind and makes your workout not only feel better but makes it more effective is game changing)

  • Grown an inch (no magic here - that's the power of good posture!)

  • Realized I wasn't broken (which was how I felt for years due to injuries and a car accident). I'm strong and capable of way more than I believed.

  • Collected tools for modifying any activity I do so that I don’t re-injure myself

  • Learned how to pull myself out of my head be present

. . .and oh, yeah, it’s now also my career. Getting to share the tools that have meant so much to my own life still feels like a gift.

Pilates and yoga have both grown in popularity since I first started practicing them. More and more people are hearing about the benefits and are curious to try them out. . . but they're not quite sure where to start.

Common questions I get are. . .

“Pilates? Yoga? What’s the difference? Which one is be better for me?”

Well, Let’s start with the similarities.

Pilates and yoga are both mindful movement practices, based on a belief that health & fitness are essential to living a full, happy life.

They both:

  • Emphasize breathing & coordinating breath with movement

  • Require little-to-no equipment

  • Improve balance, coordination, flexibility and functional strength

  • Offer great low impact exercise for all ages, sizes and ability levels

The differences are less about the movements and more about the intent behind them


female yoga teacher in 3 side by side images, one assisting a student in extended warrior pose, one in a low lunge position and one assisting a student in revolved pigeon pose

YOGA is. . .

An ancient spiritual practice with the ultimate goal of achieving inner peace.

In the United States, yoga is mostly a physical practice, but the movements (called asanas) are only one component of yoga.  Meditation, breath work, and lifestyle are core components of a full practice.

There are several styles of yoga to fit a variety of needs and preferences, from slow, meditative and restorative to very athletic.
Some common styles are:

  • Hot/Power/Bikram

  • Vinyasa

  • Hatha

  • Yin

  • Restorative

Yoga can be great if you. . .

  • Need more mobility (Do you often feel stiff or say “I’m not flexible.”)

  • Possess basic balance & stability

  • Want to build flexibility, coordination, & mindfulness

  • Are looking for a way to recover from other activities

  • Are in need of a mental/emotional outlet

  • Are on a budget and looking for a low cost exercise option. Yoga is often more widely available and less expensive than Pilates.

Try it for yourself now. . .


female pilates teacher in 3 side by side images of 3 pilates exercises, feet in straps on the reformer, double straight leg stretch on the mat and twist on the reformer

PILATES is. . .

A modern practice developed by Joseph Pilates in the early 20th century. Precisely controlled movements build strength, flexibility and joint stability.

Because of this, many people are referred to Pilates to build core strength and ease joint pain - especially back pain.

The ultimate goal is moving through life with ease, joy and the energy to do everything you enjoy.

Joseph Pilates designed his system to be done:

  • in his studio

  • with a teacher

  • on equipment that uses springs to create resistance.

He also developed a collection of exercises that could be done at home, without equipment, between sessions.
There are now options for practicing Pilates on the traditional equipment in a studio or at home - with or without props.

Pilates can be great if you. . .

  • Need more stability (You may be too flexible or have joint or balance issues.)

  • Have injuries or limiting conditions that make you nervous to workout (equipment based Pilates is best for this)

  • Are looking for an all-around fitness program - a balance of strength and flexibility

  • Prefer or need more personal attention (Pilates classes are often limited to 4-6 students).

  • Are less price sensitive. Pilates tends to cost more than other workouts due to the small class sizes, equipment and comprehensive training required for Pilates instructors.

Try it for yourself now. . .

This class uses a theraband to mimic the resistance of using the Pilates equipment.


yoga & pilates are both comprehensive practices designed to ease tension in the mind and body.

Yoga at its heart is an Eastern spiritual practice.

Pilates at its heart is a physical practice.

Lisa Day Harvey

Known for her knowledge of the body and empowering positivity, Lisa Day Harvey is a Pilates teacher in Jupiter, FL.

Born and raised in the San Francisco Bay Area, Lisa was initially drawn to Pilates to relieve the pain of multiple neck, back and shoulder injuries (a car accident, sports injuries, and concussions among them), worsened by long work days at a desk. After years of working with one specialist after another and trying seemingly everything else with little success, she was amazed at how quickly she not only found relief from pain but additionally built strength, toned and reshaped her body, improved coordination and posture (growing almost a full inch due to spinal decompression), and regained a sense of ease and delight in her body.

This experience of transformation led her to become a teacher, now specializing in working with injuries and chronic pain.

Based on her own experiences, Lisa believes that pain is simply the body’s way of asking you to do something differently and that injuries can be your greatest teachers if you slow down and pay attention to their signals. Having experienced the possibility of moving without pain first hand, she delights in empowering her clients with the knowledge, tools and felt experience to challenge, strengthen and enjoy their bodies

http://www.LisaDayHarvey.com
Previous
Previous

The Power of a great teacher

Next
Next

Good Posture Is Sexy. . . And Good For You